Difference between Perfect and Imperfect multicollinearity

July 19, 2017
Study smarter
Multicollinearity, VIF diagnostics and the rest of the classical regression assumptions are covered in the Statistics Made Simple Complete Bundle — textbook plus 1,569 practice questions with worked answers, 18 datasets and R and Stata workshops.

Imperfect multicollinearity

  • With imperfect multicollinearity, an independent variable has a strong but not perfect linear function of one or more independent variables.
  • This also means that there are also variables in the model that effects the independent variable.
  • In other words If there are two independent vairables that are related to each other. Yet there are also other vairables out of the model that effects one of the independent variable which means that there is no perfect linear function between the two only. Thus, the inlcuson of a stochastic term in the model shows that the existence of other vairables are also effecting the regressors.
  • Imperfect multicolinearity varies in degree to degree according to the sample size.
  • The presence of the error term dilutes the relstionship between the independent vairables.

Mathematically and Graphically:

imperfect multicollinearity graph

perfect multicollinearity

The equations tell us that there might be a relationship between X1 and X2 but it does not explain that X1 is to be completely explained by X2; there is a possibility of unexplained variations as well, in the form of the stochastic error term.

Perfect collinearity

The word perfect explains that a variation in one explanatory variable can be completely explained by movements in another explanatory variable.

A perfect relationship between two variables would be somewhat like:

perfect multicollinearity 2

Where:  is the constant and the Xs are the independent variables. Since there is no error term in the equation, it can be stated that x1 can be exactly explained by X2.Perfect multicollinearity is easy to discover compared to imperfect multicollinearity.

To detect perfect multicollinearity:

  1. If one variable is equal to the multiple of another variable
  2. If one variable is derived by adding the constant to another variable
  3. If a variable equals the sum of two other variables.

OLS, in this case, is not capable of generating or estimating outcomes. Because multicollinearity ruins the ability to estimate the coefficients because the two variables cannot be distinguished.

 

Related Posts

Simpson’s Paradox Explained: When Aggregate Data Lies to You

Treatment A beats Treatment B in every single subgroup of patients — and yet, combine all the subgroups together, and Treatment B wins overall. This isn't a contradiction or a calculation error. It's a real, well-documented phenomenon called Simpson's Paradox, and the...

Outlier Detection: The IQR Method, Z-Scores and What to Do Next

A single data-entry typo — a salary of $5,000,000 instead of $50,000 — can single-handedly move a mean, inflate a standard deviation, and quietly wreck a regression model. The Statistics Made Simple Complete Bundle covers exactly how to catch outliers like this before...